REUTERS/Toby Melville

New ‘most-cited’ legal scholars list includes big names, few women

(Reuters) – Retired federal appellate decide and regulation professor Richard Posner is probably the most cited U.S. legal scholar on document, adopted by Harvard College regulation professor Cass Sunstein, and the late New York College regulation professor Ronald Dworkin.

That’s in response to Yale Regulation librarian Fred Shapiro, who analyzed the regulation evaluate article and e book citations of hundreds of legal teachers and jurists for a new list of the 50 most-cited legal scholars of all time, which seems within the newest version of the College of Chicago Regulation Evaluate.

Shapiro’s list, which includes citations by 2020, includes many acquainted names, together with Harvard regulation professor Laurence Tribe at No. 4; former U.S. Supreme Courtroom Justices Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr and Antonin Scalia at Nos. 6 and 39, respectively; and former Yale regulation dean and federal appellate decide Guido Calabresi at No. 25.

But it surely’s additionally producing dialogue amongst legal teachers about who’s all however lacking from the list: women. College of Michigan regulation professor Catharine MacKinnon is No. 40. Stanford regulation professor Deborah Rhode, who died earlier this yr, is the one different women to make the lower, at No. 45.

In his article, Shapiro cited the “historical scarcity” of women within the legal academy, prejudice in opposition to women regulation professors and the better calls for women face exterior the office as causes for the imbalance. However he mentioned there may be cause to consider that extra women will be a part of the ranks of most-cited legal scholars within the coming years.

A separate list he compiled of the 20 most-cited legal scholars born in 1970 or later includes six women, with New York College regulation professor Rachel Barkow and Yale regulation professor Oona Hathaway touchdown within the high 10.

Shapiro’s evaluation discovered that among the many 50 most-cited legal scholars, most taught or train at both the College of Chicago or Harvard, with 15 every, adopted by Yale at 13. Seventeen of the scholars obtained their regulation levels from Harvard adopted by Yale with 16.

Learn extra:

These regulation colleges are tops in scholarship

Stanford Regulation convention celebrates legal ethics titan Deborah Rhode

Source link