Information Blocking Rule: Key Considerations for 2022

Whereas the Workplace of the Nationwide Coordinator for Well being Information Expertise (ONC) issued the 21st Century Cures Act; Interoperability, Information Blocking, and the ONC Health IT Certification Program (Information Blocking Remaining Rule) again in Might 2020, many entities are nonetheless parsing out compliance methods and searching for extra regulatory steerage to know how the rule shall be enforced.  Broadly-speaking, data blocking is a apply that’s more likely to intrude with, stop, or discourage entry, alternate, or use of digital well being data (EHI).  For instance, a well being system may require affected person written consent earlier than sharing the affected person’s EHI with unaffiliated suppliers.  One other instance of data blocking is {that a} well being IT developer may cost a payment to a well being care supplier to carry out an export of EHI in order that the supplier can swap to a distinct well being IT platform.

Overview of the Information Blocking Remaining Rule

As a reminder, these entities lined by the Information Blocking Remaining Rule are well being care suppliers, well being data networks or well being data exchanges, and well being IT builders of licensed well being IT (collectively, Information Blocking Actors). Information blocking is outlined by the ONC as a apply that’s more likely to intrude with entry, alternate, or use of EHI, until the apply is roofed by an exception or is in any other case required by regulation. The usual for data blocking for builders, networks or exchanges is that if they know, or ought to know, that such apply is more likely to intrude with entry, alternate, or use of EHI. For well being care suppliers to have interaction in practices thought of data blocking, the supplier would wish to know that such apply is unreasonable and is more likely to intrude with entry, alternate, or use of EHI.

EHI Definition Modifications

The ONC gives advisory updates via FAQs to Information Blocking Actors. ONC’s current FAQ steerage round how Information Blocking Actors ought to navigate the data blocking guidelines and different related legal guidelines highlights the shifting parameters across the sharing of EHI following the discharge of the Remaining Rule. Particularly, ONC touched upon the approaching change within the definition EHI for the needs of data blocking.

ONC reminded Information Blocking Actors that till October 6, 2022, EHI as outlined within the Remaining Rule is restricted to the subset of EHI represented by information components in the USA Core Knowledge for Interoperability model 1 (USCDI v1). USCDI v1 information components embody:

Allergic reactions and Intolerances


Evaluation and Plan of Remedy

Affected person Demographics

Care Crew Member(s)


Medical Notes




Well being Issues

Smoking Standing


Distinctive System Identifier(s) for a Affected person’s Implantable System(s)

Laboratory assessments and outcomes

Important Indicators

Starting on October 6, 2022, the definition of EHI within the context of Information Blocking beneath the Remaining Rule will broaden past USCDI v1. As an alternative of EHI being restricted to the USCDI v1 information components listed above, the EHI shall be outlined as digital protected well being data (PHI) to the extent that it might be thought of PHI and be included in a delegated document set as outlined within the HIPAA Privateness Rule. In different phrases, based mostly on the concept that Information Blocking Actors are already acquainted with the method of figuring out digital PHI, the EHI definition going into impact in late 2022 will symbolize the identical digital PHI {that a} affected person would have the appropriate to request a duplicate of beneath to the HIPAA Privateness Rule.

In keeping with the Remaining Rule, the preliminary limitation of Information Blocking to the subset of EHI described in USCDI v1 was established to create a clear, predictable start line for sharing EHI whereas actors put together for the sharing of all EHI.

ONC additionally inspired Information Blocking Actors to reply to requests for entry, alternate, or use of EHI with as a lot EHI as potential in an effort to promote interoperability and to apply making use of the exceptions. Compared to the far narrower set of information components, this definition of EHI, inclusive of all digital PHI in a delegated document set, is way more in depth from a protection standpoint for Information Blocking Actors. Although October 6, 2022 is nearly a yr away, Information Blocking Actors needs to be phasing these EHI scoping adjustments into their operations sooner reasonably than later.

Civil Financial Penalties for Information Blocking

On April 24, 2020, the Division of Well being and Human Providers Workplace of Inspector Basic (OIG) issued a proposed rule to amend the Civil Financial Penalty Regulation (CMP Regulation) to permit the OIG to impose civil financial penalties (CMPs) for data blocking.  The OIG could be approved to impose CMPs to not exceed $1 million per violation on Information Blocking Actors that the OIG determines dedicated data blocking. In making a dedication to impose CMPs, the OIG would think about the next components:

  • The character and extent of the data blocking;

  • The hurt ensuing from such data blocking;

  • The variety of sufferers and suppliers affected; and

  • The variety of days the data blocking endured.

Although the OIG originally intended to finalize these adjustments in September 2021, the ultimate rule continues to be pending. Throughout this ready interval, it’s price noting that the proposed rule supplied some element round OIG’s enforcement expectations and coordination with different companies such because the Workplace for Civil Rights (OCR). Particularly, the OIG acknowledged that its enforcement priorities could be would goal conduct that:

  • resulted in, is inflicting, or had the potential to trigger affected person hurt;

  • considerably impacted a supplier’s capability to care for sufferers;

  • was of lengthy period;

  • precipitated monetary loss to Federal well being care applications, or different authorities or personal entities; or

  • was carried out with precise data.

With reference to working with OCR, the OIG acknowledged within the proposed rule that it might refer an data blocking declare to OCR if a session relating to the well being privateness and safety guidelines promulgated beneath HIPAA would resolve an data blocking declare.

Moreover, from a criticism course of standpoint, well being IT builders ought to think about that ONC receives Information Blocking complaints in opposition to well being IT builders via the Information Blocking Portal, although ONC doesn’t obtain complaints in opposition to another kind of Information Blocking Actor. The ONC shares complaints of data blocking with the OIG in order that the OIG can examine and, as soon as the CMP authorities for data blocking are finalized, decide whether or not to impose CMPs.


Many Information Blocking Actors have probably wanted to make adjustments to their operations and knowledge entry insurance policies through the previous few years to adjust to the Information Blocking Remaining Rule. Together with reviewing examples supplied within the Information Blocking Remaining Rule as to what constitutes data blocking from ONC’s perspective, and the eight exceptions to the Information Blocking Rule, Information Blocking Actors ought to keep in mind to evaluate whether or not the EHI they entry, alternate, or use meets the EHI definition within the Information Blocking Remaining Rule now and later in 2022, when the definition is expanded to align with the HIPAA Privateness Rule.

Source link